Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Isaac Lewis's avatar

Nani Misbah is a fantastically talented writer -- I certainly hope that anyone who can write with such dexterity at the age of eighteen will continue creating literature, as they clearly have the gift.

Things I noted:

- evocative and fitting use of imagery -- the whole tale is, in essence, one extended metaphor, which branches out into "submetaphors" appropriately -- this is quite hard to pull off (many older writers try to "force" imagery and metaphors, which rarely works)

- clear, concrete and sensory language -- I liked "sunk his worn hands into the water" (farmers do indeed have "worn hands"), and "his eyes were wider than eyes ought to be".

- stylistically, the sentences are very euphonic and flow nicely (like a babbling stream, hmm...). This is quite hard to do (you basically need to have spent a few years cultivating an "ear" for beautiful language -- some say teenage years are the best time for this). Words and meanings are also blended together well.

- dramatically, the story carries a powerful message, and tells it in a way that "rings true"

One minor point:

- sometimes unnecessarily complicated synonyms are used, that don't have exactly the right meaning, or connotations, for the sentence in question. For example, in "the tale expounded that in the streams’ babbling and jabbering", "expounded" is not quite used correctly. Strictly speaking, a person expounds, a tale or story would *be expounded*. Similarly, "expound" often implies a lecture or classroom lesson... while a story or tale might be "told" or "narrated". "The tale told of how the stream..." might be better.

I wasn't sure if this was worth mentioning here -- but choosing words exactly is a key part of cultivating a unique style, so may be worth paying attention to.

---

Anyway, great job! :)

Caroline Beidler, MSW's avatar

Thanks so much for sharing. I'd love to connect about a storytelling platform I'm working on for recovery stories. Would love to share your story!! If interested, you can shoot me a message at circleofchairssubmissions@gmail.com.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?